Think about your assertion. What do you mean by "kids on the bubble?" Kids on the bubble in terms of top 10 teams? Those kids would be recruited by dozens of non-top 10 schools in a heartbeat. Top 50 school "Kids on the bubble"? Those kids would surely be recruited by non-top 50 schools. The most I would concede that there are rare cases where it makes a difference in a kid wanting to go to a particular school whose coach gives a damn about the actions during a game of a coach the kid has when she is 16 years old. If I'm a coach who believes a kid might have the abilities to help my team, I couldn't care less what the kid's coach acts like on the field. How is that a reflection of how the kid might perform in college. Is the kid supposed to make the coach stop? I would look at how the kid responds to the actions of the coach to assess mental/emotional toughness, focus, respect for authority, etc. A D1 coach told me that she carefully watches how the recruit interacts with her parents, coaches and teammates. She specifically said she couldn't care less what TB team my kid plays for as long as she is seeing the best pitching she can as often as possible. She knows the TB coaches in SoCal, probably personally dislikes/disrespects some, but she never mentioned any my kid shouldn't play for. That is far from a broad survey but I suspect it is representative of the majority as it seems common sensical. Lastly, some of the top players, year after year here in SoCal, play for coaches who are well known by all to yell crap at players and blues on a fairly consistent basis. I frankly can't believe the stuff I hear from one in particular. Next year, I believe three players who have been on his team for at least the past two years will be playing in the PAC-10. I've spoken with him between games and he is actually very personable and engaging. I suspect college coaches find him quite pleasant to talk to about players.
I don't recall ever hearing about the coach or the team in this thread before now. I don't know what happened and I've expressed my disdain for the behavior of some coaches. Call him on it, good for you. Maybe he'll think twice next time before reacting. But based upon my experiences and what I've heard about college coaches, I doubt that this coaches actions on the field will significantly impact the recruiting of his players. Except where they relate to his ability to teach them the game.
John



























