Blind Squirrel wrote:ntheknow wrote:Stratos,
Players can learn from game experiences, but they don't get better playing games. This is one of the biggest fallacies that parents have. If a player wants to get better, or a parent wants to see their dd get better, then they should encourage them to practice, not play 40-50 games during the summer.
Players don't get better playing games? Have you ever, one time, heard a pro (or even big time college) player or coach say that players don't get better by actually playing? Name one. Provide the link. Ever hear players/coaches talk about seeing great practice players who don't perform in games? How could that possibly be? Why do some MLB players coming off extended time on the DL play games in the minors when they could just practice with their MLB peers? What could possibly be the point?
It isn't a fallacy. It is common sense. As is the importance in development of both practice and actually playing in games. I've watched too many kid's skills deteriorate/plateau because Mommy/Daddy wanted to tell folks their kid played for a big name team and the kid rode the bench 95% of the time. Very sad to see.
John
I think everyone is saying the same thing just need to put it together and it makes sense.
In order to improve as a player, an athlete needs to practice, compete, and train. Any one or two of these cannot be separate from the others. True: playing only a lot of games and not practicing or training won't help an athlete to improve. Nor does practice alone. Nor does training alone. All three need to be present.
I believe what Hammer says is true. In southern states where the weather cooperates, there is more opportunity to do all three. Here in northern Indiana, there is a period of time when softball had to go indoors. Indoor practice facilities are a premium. Hitting is the most common practice when we go indoors. Some fielding drills can be practiced but that is limited. There are indoor tournaments but IMHO that's just not the same as playing outdoors.
We've been to tournaments where the girls from Texas, Cali and Bama were awesome to watch. There is some really good players from there and they obviously have worked hard at it.