Screwball2 wrote:Did we make a mistake by putting my daughter on an 18u team? She is a '97 pitcher/2016 and competes well in 18u. Would 16u have been better?
Yes. Unless she is on a "real" 18u Gold team. And very, very few 8th graders will be competing well on a real 18u Gold team. A lot of parents/players want to play up just to able to say that they play 18u. When the "18u team" they are on and the teams they are regularly playing against are actually competing at a 14u-level ball. College coaches don't watch those kind of teams.
A quality 16u team playing a great showcase schedule and getting time on the main complex when they do, will get a top 8th grader a lot more college exposure than an average 18u team playing on secondary fields and against bad opponents. But in my opinion, she should be competing on a 14u team that can compete for a top finish at nationals if she is really that good.