tcannizzo wrote:AlwaysImprove wrote:College coaches, as do all high end gold team coaches and most 16u A coaches view the mask as a sign of a player that is afraid of the ball. Period. End of story..
Hooey!
If that's the case, then the same should go for face guards on batting helmets. But it seems to me that I saw several in the WCWS.
You will not see a batting helmet face guards on players from certain teams. It has taken about 10 years since face guards were mandatory across all youth sanctioning bodies for a few players with masks to show up.
As far as trends, there was a college season about 7 years ago where face guards had their best shot. There were about 6 kids on TN, 4 or 5 on UW, a few on TX, etc., wearing masks. Seemed like every team had at least 3 or 4 players with masks. In the spring of that season a great batter at the time took a ball to the face and broke her jaw. By the following year that number fell back off to what you see as the current trend.
Since that year we have a steady low noise level of mask appearances. On top 100 Div 1 teams you will rarely see more than one player with a mask in the dugout. Often you see a player wear one year, but not the following. I do not see a wave of adoption.
It is extremely competitive on these college teams. They compete for every at bat, for every inning on the field. There is not just one player trying to take your spot, there 18 players on the team, they are all good and most of them play multiple spots. The typical college coaches thinking is that you see the ball better without the mask being in the way. You may agree, you may disagree with this thought, but it does not matter. You tell an 18-20 year old lady that coach thinks she may see the ball better without all that metal in the way, she is going to get in there in and compete.
As far as fielding masks. They are way behind the batting helmet mask debate. You will likely see every kid in college with a batting helmet mask and ncaa requiring batting helmet masks before the discussion on fielding masks begins. To me, right now, the batting helmet mask trend for college is not even on the horizon.
I do not see the fielding mask going the way of batting helmet mask at the youth level. You see it take off in certain areas, in certain groups, then it dies off again. When you go to nationals at 16A or above you will only see a 2-4 kids wearing fielding masks.