Is the winner of every tournament execpt ASA Nationals or PGF Trophy hunting? This isnt a jab at you by any means! I just see that term used alot and its normally a negative statement. Im just wondering what tournaments are OK to win without someone saying a coach is trophy hunting?
I guess what im saying is in most cases (but not all) the winner of any tournament probably didnt get enough competition. Would a great Cali team that works hard and passes up the other teams be expected to say to their team "we are to good and could possibly win a National Championship so we are going to play up and finish in the middle of the pack"? If a team follows the guide lines or rules set fourth by Little League as far as staying within boarders for players and they are able to pull something like that off shouldnt it be celabrated instead of condemed?
The difference is that LL is by definition an ALL-STAR TEAM. ASA, PGF, USSSA, USFA, TCS, IFA, etc are all known as TB play in some form or fashion. However, where I come from, LL all-star (or Pony or whatever all star is in your area) means that kids are divided equally in a draft format onto different teams or something similar and then play league play. The winning team's coaches then pick different kids from the league teams to make up an all-star team. Sometimes only one kid from each team but a group of allstars based on the players performance during the season.
Now I can imagine a way to make this work - spread the girls from one travel ball team around the entire league, keeping enough of them on a single team with the main coaches to win league, play the league out and then pick up each of those girls to put them back together. I guess you could call this an allstar team, but I doubt this was the way it was done.
I won't go so far as to say trophy hunting, but I will throw out there that I don't think this was in the spirit of the bylaws of the LL charter. However, they found a loop hole and that is the way it played out. Suspect that this will happen next year in other areas of the US and eventually the LL will just become another TB forum.
I honestly hope that I am wrong, as this is one of the last places that true rec ball exists in our area for any kid to play softball outside of TB programs. Not all girls want to play full time softball but enjoy it during it's season.