I saw a game with a runner on first base after a base hit. The pitcher was in the circle, but her foot is not on the rubber.The 1st baseman and 3rd baseman were near the circle, waiting for the catcher to give the pitching sign.Timeout has not been asked for or given. The runner on first stole 2nd while the pitcher was in the circle but her foot was still not on the rubber. No attempt was made to get the runner since nobody expected her to steal in that situation. The runner was ruled safe.
I saw a different game (different umpires) where the runner was on 2nd, with the same situation as above, but the runner was ruled out even though she ran straight to the bag.(as did the runner mentioned above) Both games were played under ASA rules.Which ruling is correct?
I have heard multiple opinions both ways but not a clear interpretation of the rule.