Dittoz,
I may be stepping on a land mine here but I have been ruminating over the picture of your daughter’s mechanics and the discussion that surrounded it and I didn’t really comment because I am not really here as a coach and if I were it would have to be as a baseball rather than a fastpitch softball coach. But it has been bugging me. In my opinion your DD’s picture is a nearly perfect example of a bat that is too long.
So many say that a softball swing is different than a baseball swing and I don’t really want to start that argument but certain aspects are simple physics mechanics. So what I am going to do is evaluate your DD’s swing in the picture from a baseball and physics point of view and let the debate begin.
At contact the bat should be parallel with the shoulders on the x axis (back shoulder drops to compensate for bat head drop) and the hip should be parallel with shoulders on the z axis (equally turned, which is actually pretty good). What I see in your DD’s picture is a classic “knobs up” hitting example where the bat head lags behind and drops. The top hand (trailing) elbow should not be dramatically below the top hand at contact. The back of the top hand should be facing down and the back of the bottom hand should be facing up with both wrists extended, not bent. The bottom hand elbow should be extended but not locked. In the picture if you imagine lowering the top hand to the same plane as the ball it all straightens out. If this is an example of a good swing, then that bat is either too long or too end-heavy for her.
Here is an example of a ten year old boy hitting the same high pitch. His mechanics are near perfect.
I hope this works, I've never added and image
