by Skarp » Wed Jan 27, 2010 2:03 pm
I'm pretty sure the Nokona "conditioner" is just petroleum jelly, which is what they strongly recommended before they came out with their own product.
Petroleum jelly is what I use, because it softens the leather without absorbing into the glove. And it has the added benefit of lifting out dirt when you wipe it off. I initially only use it to help form the creases (the flex lines) between the heel and pocket. Then, after the creases are well-formed, it's lots of catch and, my best advice, catching balls off of a pitching machine. With someone feeding she can get hundreds of hard catches and a well-formed pocket in a short period of time. Then, yeah...always store it with a ball in the pocket.
Later, during use, I periodically condition the glove all over with petroleum jelly, to clean it and protect the leather from cracks, etc.
It seems like everyone has a different opinion about how to best break gloves in. I rejected most of the crackpot sounding ideas (soaking, baking, etc.), and didn't like the idea of a heavy, oil-drenched glove, so Nokona's advice was the most attractive to me. It has worked very well for us.
There is no charge for awesomeness
...or attractiveness.