by Vess Express » Thu Jan 24, 2013 1:11 pm
It's all about the numbers. 5A has more students, more players, more parents, more alumni. More people to post about them.
They have in the neighborhood of what, 400-500 students per class year? Whereas a 1A - 2A school has about 100 (or fewer) per class. It should not be that surprising that the best 5A teams would be better than the best 1 or 2A teams, simply because out of 1600+ students (9th -12th) in a 5A schoold, you should be able to find 9 pretty good players. Try finding 9 pretty good players when you only have 400 to choose from. (And, of course, about half of those are boys, so make that 200 students to choose from).
I don't really care if my dd could be on the "best" 5A softball team in Texas. It might nice, but we did not choose her school on that. We specifically wanted a smaller school, with a good academic record, good atmosphere, and competetive athletic teams. I don't use HS to try and prove whether or not my dd is a good softball player. That is what travel ball is for. Give your kid a break, and let them enjoy HS a little.