FPdaddy wrote:UMPINVA,
I appreciate your opinion and have nothing but respect for umpires.
Would you have tossed her because she hit the batter OR because of her comment afterwards?
The reason I ask is...there is NO WAY you could determine if she threw at the batter on purpose. My DD hits about one batter every tourney TOTALLY by accident. We DO NOT want baserunners! So I assume you wouldn't toss an 11 year old girl for hitting a batter?!? Now, if you would have run her for her comments, I could understand that.
This brings up the point...why don't blues or TD's take a more proactive approach to all the negative cheering?
I guess you had to be there...it really was funny.
Keith
If this really happened, I can assure you I would have tossed her. There is no doubt. The mimimum would be a big time warning, but at that age, she would have likely been ejected. There is a way I could have determined it was on purpose, she said it! I dont need proof beyond a reasonable doubt, I am judge jury and executioner.
Regarding negative cheering.. its a fine line.. and a rough one to walk as an umpire.. and frankly, sometimes its pretty miserable when both teams are going at each other with them. I dont have an answer for it.. the few times I've made the mistake of mentioning it, it gets worse, louder, and parents get ticked etc. They may not do the same cheer.. but the next one is full bore fire.